- Joined
- Mar 9,
I've owned VMCs with both Fanuc and Mitsubishi controls in the past. The VMC with a Fanuc 0i-M control was a model, and the VMC with the Mitsubishi M70 was built in . Despite starting with the newer, better machine, I had a much better time using the old VMC with a Mitsubishi control -
because it doesn't suck as much to use.
Nevertheless, I know that Fanuc is far more popular than Mitsubishi in the USA.
I am here to ask why they are so popular and prevalent, because there must be a bunch of good reasons for it that I am not aware of. I just spoke with the owner of a machine tool company today and he said the Fanuc controls he buys are usually about 20% more expensive for the equivalent of a Mitsubishi in terms of hardware for the whole machine. Am I missing something?
dandrummerman21
Stainless
- Joined
- Feb 5,
- Location
-
Detroit, MI
People don't like change.
If a buyer has only used Fanuc at their old jobs, they'll likely buy it because they "know it"
I've been in the industry 15 years and we only have fanuc machines (I deal with 10 cnc mills, with 0, 15m, 21m, and 16i controls). but also had a couple years of machine shop in highschool with a haas control.
If I was in a situation where I suddenly had my own business and had to buy a used machine, I'd probably get something with a fanuc control, because I KNOW the controls very well, and I know decently well how to service them. And I know people who can help out with fanuc-specific issues if I can't.
If I was able to buy a new machine, though, I'd be open to buying something with good user reviews.
Kingbob
Stainless
- Joined
- Dec 1,
- Location
-
Louisiana
Fanuc is prevalent because it used to be GE Fanuc. General electric and
Fuji
Automatic
Numerical
Control got together in the 70's and basically invented the modern cnc control. The have market share because they largely created the market.
SeikiCorp
Hot Rolled
- Joined
- Jun 9,
- Location
-
Phoenix, Arizona
Fanuc has a much longer life cycle for control support.
15 years after a control is no longer made, the critical parts are still available or a 'upgrade' replacement is available.
Vancbiker
Diamond
- Joined
- Jan 5,
- Location
-
Vancouver, WA. USA
Fanuc is prevalent because it used to be GE Fanuc. General electric and Fuji Automatic Numerical Control got together in the 70's and basically invented the modern cnc control. The have market share because they largely created the market.
You need a bit of a history refresh. GEFanuc was established in the mid 80s, long after Fanuc had reached dominance in the controls market.
Last edited: Jan 10,
I am here to ask why they are so popular and prevalent, because there must be a bunch of good reasons for it
They actually support their stuff for
decades. I dislike Fanuc a lot but have to admit, their stuff is dependable and lasts forever
and you can get parts thirty years after everyone else tells you "Oh that's too old !" on something from .
Kingbob
Stainless
- Joined
- Dec 1,
- Location
-
Louisiana
You need a bit of a history refresh. GEFanuc was established in the mid 80s, long after Fanuc had reached dominance in the controls market.
You need a bit of a history refresh. GEFanuc was established in the mid 80s, long after Fanuc had reached dominance in the controls market.
Yes sir I understand, I was attributing Fanuc's current large market share in the US to their joint venture with GE.
I was attributing Fanuc's current large market share in the US to their joint venture with GE.
Nope, they weren't doodly at that time. Bendix, Allen-Badley, Cincy had their own, K&T had their own, G&L had their own, the GE was much more advanced, SWINC was even more popular. The GE-Fanuc was kinda low class.
It did get their name into circulation but it was kind of a crappy choice for real machines. Most people were upset that GE sold out. I guess if you had a you were happy tho
Kingbob
Stainless
- Joined
- Dec 1,
- Location
-
Louisiana
Nope, they weren't doodly at that time. Bendix, Allen-Badley, Cincy had their own, K&T had their own, G&L had their own, the GE was much more advanced, SWINC was even more popular. The GE-Fanuc was kinda low class.
It did get their name into circulation but it was kind of a crappy choice for real machines. Most people were upset that GE sold out. I guess if you had a you were happy tho
Right didn't they ride GE's coat tails to the top? I got these ideas from Max Holland's "When the Machine Stopped" though it's been some years since my last reading. Didn't he get into the GE Fanuc story or am I thinking of something else?
I always thought (rightly or wrongly) the the GE Fanuc things was similar to the Burgmaster Mazak situation. Sort of the eager student surpassing the master, and the 's hollowing out of US industries only sped it up.
memoryman
Aluminum
- Joined
- May 24,
- Location
-
Kitchener ,Ontario, Canada
Prior to GeFanuc, there was a Fanuc-Siemens alliance in North America called General Numeric,
Vancbiker
Diamond
- Joined
- Jan 5,
- Location
-
Vancouver, WA. USA
Fanuc already had a big market share prior to the GE joint venture. GE needed a good CNC and Fanuc wanted GE’s PLC.
Back to the OP’s topic;
IME, Fanuc and Mitsu have very similar MTBF numbers on their controls and drives. Mitsu is far less consistent on long term support. Drives and motors are pretty good, control parts not so much.
My Mori with Mitsu controls and drives is approaching 30 years old. Things like the touchscreen have not been available from Mitsu for 15 or so. Knock on wood, it has never needed any Mitsu parts or service ever. I’m concerned enough though that recently I bought all the controls, drives, motors, etc. from an identical machine being scrapped.
As far as Fanuc, I needed an 11ma motherboard a couple years ago. That control was about 35 years old at the time. Fanuc had a replacement on the shelf. Expensive yes, but available. I bought one off Ebay for $400 and got that machine going again.
GE needed a good CNC
GE kicked Fanuc's butt, but GE wanted out of manufacturing and into finance and "services" or whatever they whored the company out as ... and I guess that really is the answer to the question. Fanuc is still here, the rest long gone. And Fanuc still sells parts for controls from that era.
Vancbiker
Diamond
- Joined
- Jan 5,
- Location
-
Vancouver, WA. USA
I know you're a big fan of old US controls.... I only worked on a couple machines with GE (Whitney punch/plasma combo and a Monarch VMC) and can from experience say, they were nowhere near as good as Fanuc for uptime. If you had one go a year without some kind of trouble it was a fucking miracle. The majority of Fanuc controls of the same era went years without needing repair. On one of my training sessions at GEF, one of the instructors stated what I posted in #11 to be one of the main reasons for the merger
I only worked on a couple machines with GE (Whitney punch/plasma combo and a Monarch VMC) and can from experience say, they were nowhere near as good as Fanuc for uptime.
Ah, but
features ! And GE was nowhere near (imo) the leader of the pack, even. GA, K&T D, they would do some stuff ! The D, in the time period of which we speak, had adaptive control, dynamic offsets, the language that dr coelho wants, so much stuff.
But the tortoise won the race, and I admit, Fanuc deserved to. Their stuff isn't that great brains-wise but they are reliable and the company stands behind its stuff. I agree with you, as far as them being a good company.
I just wish some of the other control companies had lasted
- Joined
- Mar 9,
I'm getting the impression from the comments so far that there are no qualitative benefits to Fanuc over Mitsubishi or others, and it's only the "I already know how to use it" factor and the likelihood of long term parts availability that seal the deal for a lot of customers. I am skeptical that Fanuc corporation will be around and in good shape for the next 30 years like it has been for the past 50 years.
Suppose you could choose a VMC with any brand of control, and the price and motor specs were the same. Which would you choose, and why?
Suppose you could choose a VMC with any brand of control, and the price and motor specs were the same. Which would you choose, and why?
I would get the mitsubishi on my fave double-column
linear motor vmc because they put 10% into the company and are the only control that comes with it
It is one trick vmc ..... but i don't like vmc's that much so
cnctoolcat
Diamond
- Joined
- Sep 18,
- Location
-
Abingdon, VA
Fanuc was in the right place at the right time in the critical 's decade for CNC machinery. They happened to be the control of choice at the time for many of the Japanese builders that would eventually doom the American CNC goliaths to ashes.
Fanuc probably has an ever-so-slight reliability advantage over Mitsubishi.
Fanuc is an interesting company, have you ever seen the video of one of their servo-motor assembly factories that is 100% robotic? (Man only brings in parts/supplies, and hauls out finished product...) And this was years ago!
ToolCat
Last edited: Jan 11,
ViktorS
Aluminum
- Joined
- Apr 26,
Hands down Acramatic A to be honest ! But spare parts are getting hard to come by if I ever need them.
Everything is easy to use and buttons, parameters etc. are self explanatory.
It really cooks with the touch screen.
No fingerbanging one's and zero's into some obscure parameter list. Easy to set up work. Not one million buttons to press for simple tasks, or advanced tasks for that matter.
Only really three complaints,
1. Long startup/shutdown time
2. No way (known to me) to modify the programs for probing routines.
3. Can't use math when entering offsets on the home screen. Would be really nice to be able to enter /2 to set center of feature when using the haimer probe.
DouglasJRizzo
Diamond
- Joined
- Jun 7,
- Location
-
Ramsey, NJ.
Mitsu is a decent controller.
This issue seemed to be support.
MTB's and customers don't like hearing "sorry, you'll need a new drive" because some board is smoked after 15 years.
That's why Doosan dropped them, and, yeah, they used to offer Mitsu as an option. However, the support was nowhere what Fanuc's is.
CNC (Computer Numerical Control) grinding represents a transformative step in manufacturing, setting new standards for precision machining and consistent quality.
Read more
Understanding the benefits of CNC grinding is crucial for clients in Detroit, MI, where manufacturing excellence is a core expectation. This guide explores the technical and operational advantages of CNC grinding, explicitly focusing on the rigorous requirements of the Detroit industrial market.
Understanding CNC Grinding Technology
What Is CNC Grinding?
CNC grinding leverages advanced computer controls to automate the process. The process enables highly intricate operations on a range of materials, producing components that demand tight tolerances and complex geometries. The use of CNC controls eliminates guesswork and manual errors, which is critical for applications that require precision grinding and high-accuracy grinding.
Centerless Grinding Process Explained
Centerless grinding, a specialized form of CNC grinding, removes material from a workpiece without centering it between fixtures. Instead, the workpiece rests on a support and is rotated by a regulating wheel while being ground by the grinding wheel. This method is especially effective for manufacturing cylindrical components where concentricity, repeatability, and a uniform surface finish are essential.
Key Benefits of the Centerless Grinding Process:
- No need for workpiece mounting between centers or chucks
- Continuous, high-volume production is possible
- Suitable for manufacturing complex shapes and profiles
- Delivers exceptional roundness and straightness
- Reduces setup times and increases throughput
- Primary Advantages of CNC Grinding
High Accuracy
CNC grinding machines are engineered for exact manufacturing. Utilizing specialized software, every grinding operation can be programmed to micrometer-level accuracy.
Automated measurements ensure consistency across every workpiece.
Tight tolerances reduce the risk of component variance that could lead to assembly failures.
Such precision becomes vital in applications such as hydraulic, automotive, or aerospace parts, which are common in Detroit's manufacturing landscape.
Minimal variance in part geometry, thanks to automation
Reduced scrap rates and material waste
Reliable repeatability, supporting mass production requirements
Consistency and Repeatability in Manufacturing
Consistency is paramount in high-volume and high-spec projects. CNC grinding excels at delivering repeatable, high-accuracy grinding results shift after shift.
Operators use predefined programs, meaning outputs will match, regardless of the operator or production time.
Calibration and software updates further guarantee uniformity and repeatability throughout the machine's lifecycle.
How CNC Achieves Consistency
- Replicable part profiles and surface finishes
- Reduced operator dependency and potential for manual error
- Easy to scale production up or down, based on demand
Achieving Uniform Surface Finish
A uniform surface finish is often a critical specification in modern manufacturing. CNC grinding technologies have advanced to the point where even intricate designs can be finished to exacting specifications.
The precision application of abrasive materials delivers a smooth, uniform surface across all parts.
Uniform surface finishes result in better-fitting parts, improved aesthetics, and superior part performance.
Surface Finish Advantages
- Improved mating and sealing of components
- Enhanced wear resistance and operational longevity
- Reduces the need for extensive post-processing or manual finishing
- Extended Operational Benefits
Unmatched Productivity and Uptime
Unlike traditional grinding, CNC machines are designed for continuous operation, requiring only periodic maintenance for optimal performance. This capability is especially relevant for Detroit manufacturers operating in fast-paced industrial environments.
CNC grinders can maintain production 24/7, minimizing manual changeovers or fatigue downtime.
High throughput supports just-in-time manufacturing requirements.
Flexibility and Software Integration
The software-driven nature of CNC grinding provides immense flexibility:
Multiple operations (e.g., facing, taper grinding, and profiling) can be programmed and executed in a single setup.
With competitive price and timely delivery, YaoTai technology sincerely hope to be your supplier and partner.
Updates or adjustments to part specifications are easily implemented through updated programming, without physical machine modifications.
Centerless Grinding Applications in Detroit, MI
Detroit's diverse industries, from automotive and aerospace to medical devices, require exceptional precision, speed, and reliability standards, which CNC grinding delivers.
The region's automotive suppliers regularly rely on precision grinding to produce shafts, pins, and bushings to exacting tolerances.
Aerospace suppliers utilize high-accuracy grinding to meet strict federal and international standards.
Medical device manufacturers turn to CNC for consistency and repeatability, reducing regulatory risk.
Industry Applications
Cylinder and piston components for automotive applications
Hardened steel pins for industrial assemblies
High-precision surgical tools and implants
How CNC Grinding Maintains Quality and Compliance
Automated Inspection and Quality Assurance
Quality management is seamlessly integrated with CNC grinding:
Automated inspection systems, often embedded within the machine, identify deviations before they become costly defects.
Digital records provide traceability from raw materials through finished parts, supporting audits and compliance efforts.
In-process measurement for real-time feedback and adjustment
Statistical process control (SPC) for ongoing optimization
Complete documentation supporting regulatory compliance
Continuous Improvement Through Data Analytics
Modern CNC grinding solutions generate extensive operational data, which can be leveraged for:
Improving process efficiency via trend analysis
Predictive maintenance to reduce unplanned downtime
Identifying root causes of quality issues for continuous process improvement
What to Look For in a CNC Grinding Partner
ISO certifications and rigorous quality control protocols
Experience with your specific materials or part geometries
Technical support for process development and troubleshooting
The company is the world’s best mitsubishi cnc parts supplier. We are your one-stop shop for all needs. Our staff are highly-specialized and will help you find the product you need.